No, this isn’t a satirical piece about hysterical-fake-news or data-devouring-media – that comes next. It’s an observation that compressed expression whether through tweeting or newspaper headlines has led to a very short litany of power-words and cogent thoughts.
So if this is the death of anything it’s death to the end of nuance. It’s why we love actors more than politicians. Actors agonise in their silence, anguish and economy of words. I saw a review of “McMafia” which observed the series lacked sex, drama and violence. Sorry love, that’s life. What made it so good was it alluded to rather than was overt and it understated… like academics conversing with gangsters which is why I loved it.
Saturday’s Times headline was “crackdown on rip-off airline fees” …”rip-off” and “crackdown” are mindless, knockout words. May the airlines quake, protest and rebut – for them it’s game-over as it is in the face-off with Facebook. Death of, end of, collapse of, doom and murky worlds (yes, that one;’ about Cambridge Analytica).
Whilst battling through this and the icy winds it’s been hard not to think about those sleeping rough. Ambulances prowl the streets of Brighton in the morning struggling to revive frozen sleepers and today I saw an ultimate misery: a sleeping body breathing shallowly with poor, bare feet sticking out from under a grubby blanket. There is a word to describe this and our failure to deal with it.
Abject.
Recently I started reading “Utopia for Realists” by Rutger Bregman who’s described as “the Dutch wunderkind of new ideas” . Well actually they’re so new because many of his ideas go back to Plato.
He quotes economist Charles Kenny:
“The big reason poor people are poor is they don’t have enough money, and it shouldn’t come as a huge surprise that giving them money is a great way to reduce that problem”
That sounds so simplistic as to be stupid yet when you unravel it, it becomes more subtle.
In various experiments in London with the homeless, in Africa with the starving and in Canada with everyone in the town of Dauphin research shows when cash is given to the poor without condition and enough of it to be meaningful some strange things happen.
(And not this!)
They buy what they need not what someone thinks they need. They buy practical aids like spectacles, hearing aids and education. They even, in Africa, create entrepreneurial little businesses…if you have money you can buy vegetable seeds and food so you are strong enough to plant, water and tend them. The principal beneficiaries of reducing poverty by giving out money are always education and practicality, not alcohol, tobacco or drugs.
In general the left wing dislike the idea of giving out no-strings-attached cash as it’s deemed patronising and reduces their control over poverty as a political argument. And the right wing are fixated on the “don’t work don’t eat” mantra.
Both arguments are as abject as the other.
Have a great week.
Monday, 26 March 2018
DEATH TO DISASTER PANIC ATTACK ON HELPLESS
Labels:
Brighton,
McMafia,
Plato,
poverty,
Richard Hall,
rough sleeper,
Rutger Bregman
Posted by
Richard Hall
at
09:43
Monday, 19 March 2018
THE GENTLE ART OF MANAGEMENT
I have watched mismanagement played out on a micro and macro stage recently. On a micro level – in businesses I know - I have watched train crashes develop in slow motion as ill chosen words in e-mails have provoked anger and then irreconcilable differences, resignations and recriminations.
I suspect social media and digital communication may be responsible for more current catastrophes than anyone realises. Recently exposed e-mails from within Oxfam make the point. Most e-mails are poisonously incautious.
On the bigger world stage it’s fascinating that we seem to have collectively embraced a need for the “smack of firm government” … a concept which seems closer to the relationship of the egregious Jacob Rees-Mogg and his nanny than anything else.
What is it that makes Putin, Erdogan, Macron, Trump, Xi Jinping and yes even Kim Yung Un so appealing to so many? Why do people admire dictators or leaders who, with the exception of Kim Yung who is a ‘monarch’ by inheritance, emerge from nowhere. In a recent TV programme ‘Putin; the New Tsar’ the question is asked how a poor boy from a tiny flat in St Petersburg was transformed into an untouchable dictator and the richest man in the world through breath taking kleptocracy? It didn’t answer that question by the way.
Is it because we’re secretly drawn to nasty people that so many monsters succeed? How did Hitler do it? From the “cowardly pig” corporal that fellow soldiers in the first world war allegedly called him, to Supremo Nazi nightmare. Although apparently he was fond of dogs so he wasn’t all bad then. Putin likes dogs too as he showed by introducing his huge labrador to dog-hating Merkel –nice one Vladimir!
The better news is that such rotters are being ousted – Gadaffi, Sadam Hussein, Mubarak, Robert Mugabe and Jacob Zuma. But the cost of their removal is considerable.
Jim Collins in a legendary book about leadership “From Good to Great” (2001) wrote about what he called ‘Level Five Leadership’ where humility and fierce resolve triumphs over egocentricity. Leaders who are great listeners and coaches are what we need not loud-mouths.
So do we need more women at the top? Lady Barbara Judge - ironically named following her management misjudgements leading to her departure from the position of Chair of the IOD – suggests not. She sounded tough and rough-talking like most alpha men wielding the managerial mace and chain.
No, what we need are more good people to run our lives. Kind, well mannered and selfless people. The idea of thieves and thugs being in position of great power may appeal to the students of great dictators like Timur the Lame, Genghis Khan or Bonaparte but is clearly barmy.
Not everything in life is about winning.
It’s about doing things well and collaboratively. And it’s about setting a good example. Nearly all the mistakes in history are made by creating needless offence. Gentleness is a great art. Don’t underestimate it.
I suspect social media and digital communication may be responsible for more current catastrophes than anyone realises. Recently exposed e-mails from within Oxfam make the point. Most e-mails are poisonously incautious.
On the bigger world stage it’s fascinating that we seem to have collectively embraced a need for the “smack of firm government” … a concept which seems closer to the relationship of the egregious Jacob Rees-Mogg and his nanny than anything else.
What is it that makes Putin, Erdogan, Macron, Trump, Xi Jinping and yes even Kim Yung Un so appealing to so many? Why do people admire dictators or leaders who, with the exception of Kim Yung who is a ‘monarch’ by inheritance, emerge from nowhere. In a recent TV programme ‘Putin; the New Tsar’ the question is asked how a poor boy from a tiny flat in St Petersburg was transformed into an untouchable dictator and the richest man in the world through breath taking kleptocracy? It didn’t answer that question by the way.
Is it because we’re secretly drawn to nasty people that so many monsters succeed? How did Hitler do it? From the “cowardly pig” corporal that fellow soldiers in the first world war allegedly called him, to Supremo Nazi nightmare. Although apparently he was fond of dogs so he wasn’t all bad then. Putin likes dogs too as he showed by introducing his huge labrador to dog-hating Merkel –nice one Vladimir!
The better news is that such rotters are being ousted – Gadaffi, Sadam Hussein, Mubarak, Robert Mugabe and Jacob Zuma. But the cost of their removal is considerable.
Jim Collins in a legendary book about leadership “From Good to Great” (2001) wrote about what he called ‘Level Five Leadership’ where humility and fierce resolve triumphs over egocentricity. Leaders who are great listeners and coaches are what we need not loud-mouths.
So do we need more women at the top? Lady Barbara Judge - ironically named following her management misjudgements leading to her departure from the position of Chair of the IOD – suggests not. She sounded tough and rough-talking like most alpha men wielding the managerial mace and chain.
No, what we need are more good people to run our lives. Kind, well mannered and selfless people. The idea of thieves and thugs being in position of great power may appeal to the students of great dictators like Timur the Lame, Genghis Khan or Bonaparte but is clearly barmy.
Not everything in life is about winning.
It’s about doing things well and collaboratively. And it’s about setting a good example. Nearly all the mistakes in history are made by creating needless offence. Gentleness is a great art. Don’t underestimate it.
Labels:
alpha male,
Genghis Khan,
leadership,
Merkel,
Putin,
Richard Hall
Posted by
Richard Hall
at
09:35
Monday, 12 March 2018
WHAT SORT OF WORLD HAVE YOU CREATED FOR ME GRANDAD?
I spend a lot of time nowadays thinking about the future of our grandchildren and great nieces. This is not our world - it’s theirs and we are just looking after it for them for now .
What a bloody awful job we’re mostly doing. Brexit – crash there goes all the china! Trump being voted into office - ouch that’s our dog and cat both run over – fake road kill! The Italians veering to the right – Mussolini tortellini!
We ought to be ashamed of ourselves. We’re the caretakers of a wonderful world who’ve gone to sleep, woken up woozily and then in a panic made a series of sloppy mistakes so serious that we’re going to go hoarse saying “sorry”.
We’ve created our world of walls that doesn’t listen enough (cover your ears darlings …. la-la-la-la ‘can’t hear you!’) is selfish, unjust and grumbly. Theirs is better. Luckily the youth we’ve let down so badly are here to rescue us.
Airbnb and Uber demonstrate the asset-sharing concept but are grown so big the values which inspired them have drowned in dollars. Expect there to be new and more socially sensitive versions of ‘sharing’ to emerge. In Copenhagen public transport and car hire with businesses like “Let’s-Go” and “Car2Go” are so easy and cheap (around 30p a km) that no one wants to own a car.
It’s really very simple – friends share their possessions and our next generations will be much friendlier than we ever were.
Pendulums swing back so expect a resurgence of libraries in a modernised form (not those grim council-run places) communal centres of shared learning and inspiration. Places where you can eat a simple meal, drink a glass of wine and quietly read for an hour in a comfy chair.
We are talking about a simpler less materialistic world with less emphasis on flashy possessions. Not good news for old fashioned retailers and superstores. But great news for foragers of food, fun and fashion. Minimalism sounds a bit too austere for what I have in mind - think Shaker-stylish rather than Puritan-shabby.
I see the arts as becoming more important because making art – poetry, pottery, painting or live performances are just so much fun. I foresee more people abandoning career ambition for a richer lifestyle. Denmark, the happiest country in the world, is happy not least because of its sense of social support, its freedom to make life choices and its culture of generosity.
One other thing will be people seeking is global experience. No longer is there or will there be an attitude of “my home is my castle” but rather “this world is my oyster”. So many 20 + year olds go to Athens, Istanbul or Barcelona for a weekend….less expensive than going to Leeds and more fun.
This will be their world. Why does it sound so much more fun and so simple? Because it will be. Let’s applaud and help them get there.
What a bloody awful job we’re mostly doing. Brexit – crash there goes all the china! Trump being voted into office - ouch that’s our dog and cat both run over – fake road kill! The Italians veering to the right – Mussolini tortellini!
We ought to be ashamed of ourselves. We’re the caretakers of a wonderful world who’ve gone to sleep, woken up woozily and then in a panic made a series of sloppy mistakes so serious that we’re going to go hoarse saying “sorry”.
We’ve created our world of walls that doesn’t listen enough (cover your ears darlings …. la-la-la-la ‘can’t hear you!’) is selfish, unjust and grumbly. Theirs is better. Luckily the youth we’ve let down so badly are here to rescue us.
Airbnb and Uber demonstrate the asset-sharing concept but are grown so big the values which inspired them have drowned in dollars. Expect there to be new and more socially sensitive versions of ‘sharing’ to emerge. In Copenhagen public transport and car hire with businesses like “Let’s-Go” and “Car2Go” are so easy and cheap (around 30p a km) that no one wants to own a car.
It’s really very simple – friends share their possessions and our next generations will be much friendlier than we ever were.
Pendulums swing back so expect a resurgence of libraries in a modernised form (not those grim council-run places) communal centres of shared learning and inspiration. Places where you can eat a simple meal, drink a glass of wine and quietly read for an hour in a comfy chair.
We are talking about a simpler less materialistic world with less emphasis on flashy possessions. Not good news for old fashioned retailers and superstores. But great news for foragers of food, fun and fashion. Minimalism sounds a bit too austere for what I have in mind - think Shaker-stylish rather than Puritan-shabby.
I see the arts as becoming more important because making art – poetry, pottery, painting or live performances are just so much fun. I foresee more people abandoning career ambition for a richer lifestyle. Denmark, the happiest country in the world, is happy not least because of its sense of social support, its freedom to make life choices and its culture of generosity.
One other thing will be people seeking is global experience. No longer is there or will there be an attitude of “my home is my castle” but rather “this world is my oyster”. So many 20 + year olds go to Athens, Istanbul or Barcelona for a weekend….less expensive than going to Leeds and more fun.
This will be their world. Why does it sound so much more fun and so simple? Because it will be. Let’s applaud and help them get there.
Labels:
Airbnb,
Brexit,
Italian election,
Mussolini,
Richard Hall,
Trump,
Uber
Posted by
Richard Hall
at
08:41
Monday, 5 March 2018
GET OVER IT - IT'S JUST A BIT CHILLY
I don’t know if you ever saw “The Day After Tomorrow” a 2004 film about a superstorm that engulfed the Northern Hemisphere in a second ice age. North America is evacuated and its population flees south to Mexico which, in delicious irony, closes its borders. Apart from Dennis Quaid the cast is pretty well unknown and looks convincingly chilly…that’s a post- apocalyptic New York below.
I was gripped by the plausibility of the horror when I saw it…at least the first part… as the storm did its work.
Last week I thought about the film again as the Siberian weather swept across Britain in what seemed like a kind of divine punishment for prevarication on Brexit. There was a photograph of the snow clouds hitting London that CGI couldn’t have bettered.
My first pragmatic reactions to all the fuss was to behave like Dennis Quaid – called Jack Hall in the film – a great name for a hero – and get out and teach the beast a lesson.
Life had to go on as usual. But then I slipped on black ice near the house and in a graceless pratfall landed on my head on the tarmac. A real banana skin moment when your life flashes before you accompanied by a symphony of bad language. I limped home to sympathy and a ban on going out until the ice had gone.
So life has slowed down and I’ve been thinking about how much better we’ve got at dealing with disaster. There’s a myth that amongst we overly self-critical Brits that we can’t cope with a bit of “weather”. Just go to Germany or America when the weather turns nasty. They stay at home apart from the odd intrepid skier. Their world stops. I’ve been impressed by our weather forecasts , by the frequency of updates and by how hard the transport system has tried to keep up with the game.
Maybe we should all take stock.
We are such a miserable bunch sometimes. Yet we are one of the most resourceful and independently minded countries in the world. Let’s use this climatic hiatus to plan what our business will do that’s amazing this summer. Or what painting, poem or novel we’re going to create.
The prospects for tomorrow are so amazing that my head hurts…or maybe that’s just the tarmac speaking to me.
Storm Emma is on the way and all I can think about is that irritating minx Jane Austen’s heroine Emma Woodhouse whose sickly father Mr Woodhouse is one of my favourite, ghastly, self-obsessed characters in literature. His attitude to alcohol is especially irksome:
“… what say you to half a glass of wine? A small half-glass, put into a tumbler of water? I do not think it could disagree with you."
But there isn’t anything that weather can throw at us – we Jack Halls – that we can’t deal with – after all this is just a bit chilly. Nothing to worry about.
I was gripped by the plausibility of the horror when I saw it…at least the first part… as the storm did its work.
Last week I thought about the film again as the Siberian weather swept across Britain in what seemed like a kind of divine punishment for prevarication on Brexit. There was a photograph of the snow clouds hitting London that CGI couldn’t have bettered.
My first pragmatic reactions to all the fuss was to behave like Dennis Quaid – called Jack Hall in the film – a great name for a hero – and get out and teach the beast a lesson.
Life had to go on as usual. But then I slipped on black ice near the house and in a graceless pratfall landed on my head on the tarmac. A real banana skin moment when your life flashes before you accompanied by a symphony of bad language. I limped home to sympathy and a ban on going out until the ice had gone.
So life has slowed down and I’ve been thinking about how much better we’ve got at dealing with disaster. There’s a myth that amongst we overly self-critical Brits that we can’t cope with a bit of “weather”. Just go to Germany or America when the weather turns nasty. They stay at home apart from the odd intrepid skier. Their world stops. I’ve been impressed by our weather forecasts , by the frequency of updates and by how hard the transport system has tried to keep up with the game.
Maybe we should all take stock.
We are such a miserable bunch sometimes. Yet we are one of the most resourceful and independently minded countries in the world. Let’s use this climatic hiatus to plan what our business will do that’s amazing this summer. Or what painting, poem or novel we’re going to create.
The prospects for tomorrow are so amazing that my head hurts…or maybe that’s just the tarmac speaking to me.
Storm Emma is on the way and all I can think about is that irritating minx Jane Austen’s heroine Emma Woodhouse whose sickly father Mr Woodhouse is one of my favourite, ghastly, self-obsessed characters in literature. His attitude to alcohol is especially irksome:
“… what say you to half a glass of wine? A small half-glass, put into a tumbler of water? I do not think it could disagree with you."
But there isn’t anything that weather can throw at us – we Jack Halls – that we can’t deal with – after all this is just a bit chilly. Nothing to worry about.
Labels:
Armageddon,
Brexit,
Jane Austen,
Mr Woodhouse,
New Year,
post-apocalyptic,
Richard Hall,
storm Emma
Posted by
Richard Hall
at
09:43
Monday, 26 February 2018
THE INVULNERABILITY OF THE OPTIMIST
We optimists awaken at dawn full of the joys of anticipation and the certainty of success and sixteen hours later we retreat to bed wounded and weakened by the ambushes from cynics, sceptics and pessimists. We sleep fitfully but the next day we wake up full of the joys of anticipation….
No wonder we are loathed by the purveyors of dystopian rhetoric and targeted as beastly balloons of cheerfulness. We are like low, slow-flying pheasants cheerfully indifferent to the shotguns of despair. We are, in short, irrepressible.
And if we listen to Steve Pinker (our cheerleader) we seem in the right. He says that we are, on every known measurement, progressing ever forwards to a better world of longer, happier, healthier and wealthier lives. His new book “Enlightenment now” has been described as heartening and inspiring. But it has enraged Black Swan author and grumpy apostle of doom, Nassim Taleb, who regards Pinker as devoid of rigour.
Sceptics like him have plenty of ammunition. The betrayal of trust by politicians, economists and bankers; the Syrian catastrophe; ISIS; Al -Qaeda; the Parkland Florida shooting; Donald Trump pretty well daily and so on. But their espousal of catastrophe is pretty thin stuff viewed against the sweep of history.
That’s not how the news sounds of course. Even some bad weather (forecast to coincide with when you are reading this in the UK or Europe) has been named “the Beast from the East”. A cold snap is demonised.
Mel Brooks, like many comics a bit of a pessimist, said: “Hope for the Best. Expect the worst. Life is a play. We're unrehearsed.” Spot on Mel. We are living in a happier, better world for sure but it’s a whole lot messier. The sense of under-rehearsal and busking is evident in the behaviour of all our politicians. Recently we saw a play called “The Play that goes Wrong”. It was a farce that felt very appropriate for our times. And we all laughed because that’s what optimistic human beings do when things mess up.
Our lives move faster. Our news is more fractured. Reactions are more erratic. Nuance is a thing of the past. Things are extreme - either good or bad. We live in a binary tick-box culture but…big but… things are getting better. Institution after institution is given a roasting - as Oxfam and others were last week. They say sorry, are reformed and then life goes on - better. This week it was the turn of the Police. The Supreme Court deemed “failures in the investigation of the crimes, provided they are sufficiently serious, will give rise to liability on the part of the police”. This related to mistakes in the original Worboys’ investigation. A real surprise for pessimists about human rights but as Steve Pinker reminds us:
“humans have innate desires for life, liberty and the pursuit of happiness.” So in the end things tend to work out in justifying our desires and our unquenchable optimism.
No wonder we are loathed by the purveyors of dystopian rhetoric and targeted as beastly balloons of cheerfulness. We are like low, slow-flying pheasants cheerfully indifferent to the shotguns of despair. We are, in short, irrepressible.
And if we listen to Steve Pinker (our cheerleader) we seem in the right. He says that we are, on every known measurement, progressing ever forwards to a better world of longer, happier, healthier and wealthier lives. His new book “Enlightenment now” has been described as heartening and inspiring. But it has enraged Black Swan author and grumpy apostle of doom, Nassim Taleb, who regards Pinker as devoid of rigour.
Sceptics like him have plenty of ammunition. The betrayal of trust by politicians, economists and bankers; the Syrian catastrophe; ISIS; Al -Qaeda; the Parkland Florida shooting; Donald Trump pretty well daily and so on. But their espousal of catastrophe is pretty thin stuff viewed against the sweep of history.
That’s not how the news sounds of course. Even some bad weather (forecast to coincide with when you are reading this in the UK or Europe) has been named “the Beast from the East”. A cold snap is demonised.
Mel Brooks, like many comics a bit of a pessimist, said: “Hope for the Best. Expect the worst. Life is a play. We're unrehearsed.” Spot on Mel. We are living in a happier, better world for sure but it’s a whole lot messier. The sense of under-rehearsal and busking is evident in the behaviour of all our politicians. Recently we saw a play called “The Play that goes Wrong”. It was a farce that felt very appropriate for our times. And we all laughed because that’s what optimistic human beings do when things mess up.
Our lives move faster. Our news is more fractured. Reactions are more erratic. Nuance is a thing of the past. Things are extreme - either good or bad. We live in a binary tick-box culture but…big but… things are getting better. Institution after institution is given a roasting - as Oxfam and others were last week. They say sorry, are reformed and then life goes on - better. This week it was the turn of the Police. The Supreme Court deemed “failures in the investigation of the crimes, provided they are sufficiently serious, will give rise to liability on the part of the police”. This related to mistakes in the original Worboys’ investigation. A real surprise for pessimists about human rights but as Steve Pinker reminds us:
“humans have innate desires for life, liberty and the pursuit of happiness.” So in the end things tend to work out in justifying our desires and our unquenchable optimism.
Labels:
Donald Trump,
Mel Brooks,
Optimism,
optimist,
Oxfam,
Parkland shooting,
pessimism,
pessimist,
Richard Hall,
Steven Pinker
Posted by
Richard Hall
at
09:38
Monday, 19 February 2018
TERRIBLE ADVICE
Rubbish solutions are in fashion
I’m not sure why this appealed so much to me but recently I was driving through Brighton behind a van emblazoned with a sign “Brighton Rubbish Solutions” and it occurred to me this was great name for a second or even third rate marketing consultancy. Mostly I guess because most advice nowadays is so suspect. Ask any economist – or rather don’t bother. I reflected further on businesses taking bold and sometimes strange decisions.
Like Jaguar. I saw their brand new Jaguar F-Pace recently. "Gosh" I thought “smart Renault!”. It bore no resemblance to Jaguar refinement. If it were a painting it would be called a forgery. An SUV solution but a bad one.
Or Tesco’s secret plans to launch a new retail concept to fight Aldi (the UK’s favourite supermarket say consumers) and Lidl. The conversations in Cheshunt where the mighty Tesco is headquartered have historically revolved around the risks to the brand and of confusing consumers in introducing a really cheap Tesco as opposed to a quite cheap Tesco. Trouble is Aldi is remarkable for its quality not just its prices. In a recent survey of 10 great value/quality grocery items in the Sunday Times Aldi had two – their prosecco and their new coffee pods – and Lidl one, their aged beef. Revealingly Tesco had none.
If they aren’t careful Tesco will end up with a rubbish solution. As Coca Cola have done in reversing their one brand strategy and relaunching their sugar free brands in isolation.
And in the world of economics Bitcoin is either a genius introduction to the future of money or it’s the next South Sea Bubble. Confusingly it could be both. Which is a rubbish situation.
In the world of politics some weird things are happening. Politicians used to yearn for “clear blue water” separating parties. Today an ocean lies between the wrathful disciples of left-wing-Momentum and the pinstriped intolerant Tory right-wing.
Let me introduce you to Jacob Rees-Mogg. America astonished the world by electing a game-show host who’s reckless, rude and crude. In the UK the bookies have two favourites for the next Prime Minister – Jeremy Corbyn (described by an American friend as Bernie Saunders without the brains) and Jacob. Ladbrokes and Coral actually make Jacob the narrow favourite.
Who is he? 48 years old. Educated Eton and Oxford. Co-founder of a Hedge Fund. He and his wife have around £100 million allegedly. He is strongly anti-Europe and advocates abrupt and total separation from the EU. He has six children. Their names are revealing: Peter Theodore Alphege; Mary Anne Charlotte Emma ;Thomas Wentworth Somerset Dunstan; Anselm Charles Fitzwilliam ; Alfred Wulfric Leyson Pius; Sixtus Dominic Boniface Christopher. The names tell a story.
He has an icy charm. He’s clever, well mannered, calm and very dangerous. But chances are – if you believe the bookmakers – he could be the next Prime Minister. Or possibly another rubbish solution.
We live in strange times.
I’m not sure why this appealed so much to me but recently I was driving through Brighton behind a van emblazoned with a sign “Brighton Rubbish Solutions” and it occurred to me this was great name for a second or even third rate marketing consultancy. Mostly I guess because most advice nowadays is so suspect. Ask any economist – or rather don’t bother. I reflected further on businesses taking bold and sometimes strange decisions.
Like Jaguar. I saw their brand new Jaguar F-Pace recently. "Gosh" I thought “smart Renault!”. It bore no resemblance to Jaguar refinement. If it were a painting it would be called a forgery. An SUV solution but a bad one.
Or Tesco’s secret plans to launch a new retail concept to fight Aldi (the UK’s favourite supermarket say consumers) and Lidl. The conversations in Cheshunt where the mighty Tesco is headquartered have historically revolved around the risks to the brand and of confusing consumers in introducing a really cheap Tesco as opposed to a quite cheap Tesco. Trouble is Aldi is remarkable for its quality not just its prices. In a recent survey of 10 great value/quality grocery items in the Sunday Times Aldi had two – their prosecco and their new coffee pods – and Lidl one, their aged beef. Revealingly Tesco had none.
If they aren’t careful Tesco will end up with a rubbish solution. As Coca Cola have done in reversing their one brand strategy and relaunching their sugar free brands in isolation.
And in the world of economics Bitcoin is either a genius introduction to the future of money or it’s the next South Sea Bubble. Confusingly it could be both. Which is a rubbish situation.
In the world of politics some weird things are happening. Politicians used to yearn for “clear blue water” separating parties. Today an ocean lies between the wrathful disciples of left-wing-Momentum and the pinstriped intolerant Tory right-wing.
Let me introduce you to Jacob Rees-Mogg. America astonished the world by electing a game-show host who’s reckless, rude and crude. In the UK the bookies have two favourites for the next Prime Minister – Jeremy Corbyn (described by an American friend as Bernie Saunders without the brains) and Jacob. Ladbrokes and Coral actually make Jacob the narrow favourite.
Who is he? 48 years old. Educated Eton and Oxford. Co-founder of a Hedge Fund. He and his wife have around £100 million allegedly. He is strongly anti-Europe and advocates abrupt and total separation from the EU. He has six children. Their names are revealing: Peter Theodore Alphege; Mary Anne Charlotte Emma ;Thomas Wentworth Somerset Dunstan; Anselm Charles Fitzwilliam ; Alfred Wulfric Leyson Pius; Sixtus Dominic Boniface Christopher. The names tell a story.
He has an icy charm. He’s clever, well mannered, calm and very dangerous. But chances are – if you believe the bookmakers – he could be the next Prime Minister. Or possibly another rubbish solution.
We live in strange times.
Monday, 12 February 2018
WHY SHOWING YOUR STRATEGY ISN'T ALWAYS SMART
There’s this constant tussle between transparency and effective management. We see it daily with the cabinet describing the need to keep their cards close their chest in Brexit negotiations as though they were tremulous poker players. Everything has been reduced to process.
My focus is on three companies this week. They are Pepsico, VW and Royal Bank of Scotland.
Pepsico has a female Chair and CEO, Indra Nooyi, who in a radio interview described a research-finding about their brand Doritos.
She said, in brief, women were put off by the loud crunching sound they made when eaten and that their dusty residue meant fingers had to be licked. Women wanted a cleaner, quieter Dorito and that’s what was going to be given to them. A piece of careful consumer research leading to a targeted segmentation of the brand. Sounds OK; sounds like Pepsico is listening.
But all hell was let loose with women on Twitter frothing with rage – “Doritos for ladies? Ridiculous” …”I will eat my crisps however I damn well please and they will no longer be Doritos”….”How can you gender-type crisps?”
Indro Nooyi is a unusually smart CEO who speaks thoughtfully. She’s a model of restraint. No doubt she was surprised that you have to be so incredibly careful nowadays about whatever you say.
And whatever you do. Step forward VW.
They have admitted to funding a research study to test the effect of diesel emissions on caged monkeys. It didn’t take long for people to describe this as a German company creating gas chambers in which to gas little monkeys. These tests took place 3 years ago and Chief Lobbyist Thomas Steg has since been suspended. You couldn’t make that one up.
Next RBS whose Global Restructuring Group (GRG) had been castigated by the Financial Conduct Authority for mistreating thousands of small and medium-sized companies. The RBS Chairman Sir Howard Davies agreed these were the findings but disputed the conclusions. This one will run and run: “we’re not guilty…not…not!”
And another thing….Andrew Krepinevitch (no me neither). He’s a senior fellow at the Centre for Strategic and Budgetary Assessments and he’s regarded as an expert on strategy.
He identifies the ten biggest strategic blunders. Here are just four of them:-
- Failure to recognize or take seriously the scarcity of resources.
- Making false presumptions about one’s own competence.
- Insufficient focus on strategy by trying to satisfy too many different stakeholders.
- Failure to understand the adversary.
I was struck by these as being pretty much the current Brexit negotiating team’s issues. They constantly overstate our national and their own importance and intelligence. They try to keep too many people happy – a hopeless quest since many are never going to be happy whatever goodies they get. The last one is obvious.
Strategy is about knowing what to do, what’s possible and how public opinion can disrupt a seemingly logical move. Easy? No it’s not. So pay attention. Even you the highly esteemed Ms Nooyi.
My focus is on three companies this week. They are Pepsico, VW and Royal Bank of Scotland.
Pepsico has a female Chair and CEO, Indra Nooyi, who in a radio interview described a research-finding about their brand Doritos.
She said, in brief, women were put off by the loud crunching sound they made when eaten and that their dusty residue meant fingers had to be licked. Women wanted a cleaner, quieter Dorito and that’s what was going to be given to them. A piece of careful consumer research leading to a targeted segmentation of the brand. Sounds OK; sounds like Pepsico is listening.
But all hell was let loose with women on Twitter frothing with rage – “Doritos for ladies? Ridiculous” …”I will eat my crisps however I damn well please and they will no longer be Doritos”….”How can you gender-type crisps?”
Indro Nooyi is a unusually smart CEO who speaks thoughtfully. She’s a model of restraint. No doubt she was surprised that you have to be so incredibly careful nowadays about whatever you say.
And whatever you do. Step forward VW.
They have admitted to funding a research study to test the effect of diesel emissions on caged monkeys. It didn’t take long for people to describe this as a German company creating gas chambers in which to gas little monkeys. These tests took place 3 years ago and Chief Lobbyist Thomas Steg has since been suspended. You couldn’t make that one up.
Next RBS whose Global Restructuring Group (GRG) had been castigated by the Financial Conduct Authority for mistreating thousands of small and medium-sized companies. The RBS Chairman Sir Howard Davies agreed these were the findings but disputed the conclusions. This one will run and run: “we’re not guilty…not…not!”
And another thing….Andrew Krepinevitch (no me neither). He’s a senior fellow at the Centre for Strategic and Budgetary Assessments and he’s regarded as an expert on strategy.
He identifies the ten biggest strategic blunders. Here are just four of them:-
- Failure to recognize or take seriously the scarcity of resources.
- Making false presumptions about one’s own competence.
- Insufficient focus on strategy by trying to satisfy too many different stakeholders.
- Failure to understand the adversary.
I was struck by these as being pretty much the current Brexit negotiating team’s issues. They constantly overstate our national and their own importance and intelligence. They try to keep too many people happy – a hopeless quest since many are never going to be happy whatever goodies they get. The last one is obvious.
Strategy is about knowing what to do, what’s possible and how public opinion can disrupt a seemingly logical move. Easy? No it’s not. So pay attention. Even you the highly esteemed Ms Nooyi.
Labels:
Doritos,
FCA,
Financial conduct authority,
NatWest,
RBS,
Richard Hall,
Royal Bank of Scotland,
strategy,
VW
Posted by
Richard Hall
at
09:43
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)



























